Fall anime season

As I promised, here is my quick review of a few of the shows airing this season. Be aware that this is only my opinion, and that just because I dislike a show doesn't mean it's necessarily bad, just not my thing.

Quick note, I'm watching a few "second seasons" this season, so my recommendation on each of them is to watch the first, then continue.

So here goes:

To Aru Majutsu no Index II (A certain magical Index II): The second season of To Aru Majutsu no Index, it pretty much picks up exactly where it left off. While a lot of season one revolved around events in Academy City, season 2 seems to mostly take place outside of the city, which is new. Lots of new characters being introduced, which is on par for a new season for any show. If you liked the first season, you'll love this one. To Aru Kagaku no Railgun (A certain scientific Railgun) is an offshoot of this show, so if you liked it, I'd highly recommend you watch through the first season, then pick up season 2.

Tegami Bachi REVERSE: I hear a lot of people trash on Tegami Bachi, but for reasons I've never really been able to pin down, I loved it, so I was really excited about the second season. As with Index II, this picks up right where the first season left off. If you liked the first season, go ahead and watch this, as it's pretty much just more of the same.

Soredemo Machi wa Mawatteiru: This show is... interesting. I love the opening animation/song, and the show itself is entertaining enough, there just doesn't seem to be much that really jumps out at me. The animation isn't great, but I've certainly seen worse. I've only watched the first episode, so maybe it picks up in 2 and 3, but I'm not sure about this show.

MM!: It's rare that I dislike a show so much that I can't watch past the first episode. I know a few people I follow on Twitter absolutely love this show, but I really didn't like it. While the voice acting and animation is pretty good, the writing and characters are, in my opinion, abysmal. The characters don't seem to have much of a personality past their personality quirks, so the main character is a masochist, and not much else. Japan's seeming obsession with things like S&M has always struck me as odd. It's like they can't think of any way to show that someone is weird besides either making them obsessed with sex, making them a hardcore otaku, or making them an M. I'd be open to watching more of it if this show actually turns into something besides random S&M humor, but I'm not holding my breath.

Ore no Imouto ga Konna ni Kawaii Wake ga Nai (My little sister can't be this cute!): As so many others have put it, I'm not going to be telling my siblings I'm watching this show. I actually really like this show so far, and as I understand it, the light novel was quite good, so I'll probably try to find a translation of that. The show's main character is the older, high-school aged brother of a middle-school girl, who is quite popular. She's a model, both in the student and picture-taking variants, but she is also a closet otaku, and plays a lot of 18+ VNs, or "eroge" (short for erotic game). Her brother finds out about this, and helps her to do things like find friends with similar hobbies. Honestly, aside from the sis-con element to the show, as evidenced by the title, this show actually has a much more realistic portrayal of the relationship between like-aged siblings than most anime/manga. If you aren't deeply offended by things like eroge and the siscon relationship, I highly recommend you watch this show. If those things do offend you, I'd honestly suggest you find a hobby besides anime, because anime is rampant with them.

Tantei Opera Milky Holmes: Most season I dislike maybe one show. This is one of the first times I have literally had to turn a show off before I was even halfway through the first episode. Maybe my standards are getting higher, or maybe this show really is that bad, but damn this show bored the hell out of me. From what I saw, this is a sort of a moe detective show, which seems like a really bad idea to me, as a lot of moe involves being, quite frankly, stupid, airheaded, or clumsy. These traits, of course, really don't lend themselves to being a detective. Now, from what I saw, it seems very likely this show is targeted at a fairly young audience. But then, so was Yumeiro Patissiere, and I absolutely loved that show. I can't in good conscience recommend anyone watch this show.

Others: There were a couple other shows I checked out, but chose not to review, nor watch. The reason for that is that I could see merit in them, but they were just not my type of show. Togainu no Chi is the only one that I can actually remember at the moment, and while I know a lot of people like BL, it just doesn't interest me. One of my biggest problems with a lot of reviewers is that they intentionally watch a show/play a game that is a genre they know they don't like, and end up reviewing the genre, rather then the game/show. (IE: every time Yahtzee touches a JRPG).

I'll post a short review of both Bakuman and Kuragehime later, but I can summarize both in one word: Watch.